NLRB Decision Sparks Student Athlete Union Debate


The NCAA has long denied college athletes the right to be viewed as employees, but as of late, a change in the system is looking more and more likely.

On March 27 in Chicago, the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) ruled that football players at Northwestern University can legally form a union. The ruling, which came in response to a petition created by ex-Northwestern football player Kain Colter along with the College Athletes Players Association (CAPA), also described the athletes on Northwestern’s football team as “employees.” This was a surprising decision that placed the power to make history in the hands of the Northwestern players, who can now form the first ever student athlete union in college sports.

The NCAA voiced its disapproval of the decision, as did Northwestern. At press time, Northwestern had yet to request a review of the ruling, but the private Illinois university has made clear that it intends to issue an appeal. Many fear that this will take the ruling all the way to the Supreme Court, and will greatly postpone any resolution. In the meantime, Northwestern football players may form a union as soon as April 25, when the athletes will vote for or against unionizing under CAPA.

In the wake of the NLRB’s verdict, opinions have been divided as to whether or not student athletes should be seen as workers who can be part of a labor union. A common argument is that athletes dedicate the same amount of hours to their sport as employees do to their occupation, and also that they deserve better medical coverage and more in-depth injury testing, which a union could help secure. Moreover, USF legal studies professor Robert Elias points out that student athletes should to be rewarded for serving as a means of revenue for their wealthy bosses, their schools, and the NCAA.

“These employees are not paid for any of the income they generate, and they also have no other benefits that employees would normally be able to secure for themselves, especially if they were to unionize,” Elias said. “If the initial NLRB decision holds up, then it means that college athletes will have a basis for getting some piece of that enormous income, in exchange for their labors.”

In contrast, there are many reasons to believe that labor unions are unnecessary for college athletes. Some argue that since players already receive many benefits from their schools, such as guaranteed housing and scholarships, they should not be paid for their efforts. Others acknowledge that there may be problems with the treatment of college athletes, but that they should be solved by the team itself, instead of enabling unions and potentially reforming the NCAA’s system. Northwestern’s head football coach, Pat Fitzgerald, sees this method as the best possible solution.

“All this can be handled with communication. It’s about trust,” Fitzgerald told the press on Saturday. “I just do not believe we need a third party between our players and our coaches, staff, and administrators…whatever they need, we will get them.”

Despite the clashing opinions that have arisen from the aftermath of the NLRB ruling, some have attempted to find a middle ground. Larry Scott, the commissioner of the Pac-12 conference, is open to an alteration in how the NCAA currently functions, but does not feel that student athletes should receive salaries.

“We absolutely should do more and I’m going to continue to push for us to do more,” Scott said in an interview with ESPN.com. “It just can’t cross that line of starting to get paid a salary or negotiating through collective bargaining. That’s a pro model, completely different.”

While it is clear that disagreement is abound and that many are hesitant to accept student athletes as employees, the reality is that by allowing Northwestern football players to unionize, the NLRB pushed us a step closer to a world where college athletes are paid to do what they do. Since the March 27 decision, multiple players from other schools have shown interest in unionizing, according to United Steelworkers member Tim Waters. If the Northwestern players do indeed vote to become a union on April 25, intrigue from players at other universities will surely increase.

The historic decision also has implications for USF and other private universities. Since the NLRB’s rulings can only cover private schools, it would be much more difficult for unionizing to be made possible at public universities, but it is conceivable that another private school could follow in Northwestern’s footsteps in the near future.

Sophomore business finance major Kenneth Lapuz is unenthusiastic about the prospect of student athletes being paid at USF.

“Going to a school where athletes are paid or are part of a union would be somewhat disastrous,” Lapuz said. “The student athletes will express no admiration for their institution whatsoever. They will merely be paid to receive an education and to play on an athletic team, not to mention the amount of power they possess since they are unionized.”



233 thoughts on “NLRB Decision Sparks Student Athlete Union Debate”

  1. John Davis’ marketing campaign: http://davisforkansas.com/ [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=doudoune-moncler-quincy-femme]doudoune moncler quincy femme[/url]
    A lot of money of tension, in truth, only strolled around. A considerable ways out of the girl Southern Camera dwelling, the noticeably tense history investigator called Kate Regulation is located all the way down having Pro Daniel Brewster. The girl pickle? A card-reader in their own Mac laptop Pro isn’t reading this images the woman required with archival records at Stanford School, where she will be a new going to instructor. Along with pictures are generally the woman meat-and-potatoes. [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=moncler-occasion-homme]moncler occasion homme[/url]
    The city would certainly obtain a proportion of the income. [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=moncler-paris-boutique]moncler paris boutique[/url]
    “I thought while using the type of folks that had been for their safeguard in addition to contributing me personally, I personally thought including I possibly could save the day earn.Inch [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=doudounes-moncler-pas-cher]doudounes moncler pas cher[/url]
    The. Rodney Dangerfield [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=moncler-collection]moncler collection[/url]
    Font ResizeMendocino City jail concerns: Might 4-May 10Ukiah Daily Record StaffUpdated: [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=vente-doudoune-moncler]vente doudoune moncler[/url]
    05/18/2014 May:Forty nine:Thirty one In the evening PDTUpdated: [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=doudoune-moncler-marron]doudoune moncler marron[/url]

  2. It is perfect time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy. I have read this post and if I could I want to suggest you few interesting things or tips. Maybe you can write next articles referring to this article. I desire to read more things about it!
    Louis Vuitton Outlet

  3. Michael jordan Lyles (5-1) gave up 6 operates on 5 gets and 6 strolls in excess of Several 1/3 innings to look at burning. [url=http://www.picketreport.com/linksports.php?p=cheap-gucci-belts]cheap gucci belts[/url]
    “not help consideration or even penetration of the USA Overall flexibility Take action [url=http://www.picketreport.com/linksports.php?p=gucci-bags-outlet]gucci bags outlet[/url]
    On Tuesday, commissioners are going to be expected to think about a various amendments to the present Region Glen Growth Arrangement. That they include: [url=http://www.picketreport.com/linksports.php?p=fake-gucci-bags]fake gucci bags[/url]
    By simply Patricia Somerville [url=http://www.picketreport.com/linksports.php?p=fake-gucci-belts]fake gucci belts[/url]
    Well Resize [url=http://www.picketreport.com/linksports.php?p=gucci-outlet-store]gucci outlet store[/url]
    nkefapvnmko Iz FIRE is actually assisting [url=http://www.picketreport.com/linksports.php?p=cheap-gucci-sunglasses]cheap gucci sunglasses[/url]
    “The secretes necessary for court conclusions are the reason for a new extraordinary variety of the serious offences classified by the particular document,In . your woman claimed. Gonzalez explained, one example is, that will required produces account for in excess of Seventy two percentage in the immigration in prison for homicide.

  4. Simply desire to say your article is as surprising. The clearness in your post is just spectacular and i can assume you are an expert on this subject. Fine with your permission let me to grab your RSS feed to keep up to date with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please keep up the enjoyable work.
    mulberry outlet

  5. Within a non-festive funk about festival flocks [url=http://danielecerioni.com/collegamento.php?p=borse-moncler]borse moncler[/url]
    “Our method was access it your bowl and take care of the exterior try to sell and that is might know about does,Inch Dondanville claimed. “John click your tennis ball inside distance and after that I obtained the one that would have been a little bit fat and got the job completed.” [url=http://danielecerioni.com/collegamento.php?p=piumino-moncler-donna]piumino moncler donna[/url]
    Content posted about Thursday, Might Twenty one, 2014 [url=http://danielecerioni.com/collegamento.php?p=smanicato-moncler]smanicato moncler[/url]
    05/14/2014 August:09:02 In the evening PDTUpdated: [url=http://danielecerioni.com/collegamento.php?p=moncler-uomo]moncler uomo[/url]
    Uploaded: [url=http://danielecerioni.com/collegamento.php?p=spaccio-moncler-trebaseleghe]spaccio moncler trebaseleghe[/url]
    Find out all you want by simply examining the whole story [url=http://danielecerioni.com/collegamento.php?p=moncler]moncler[/url]
    The bill might require any one hoping to modify the religious beliefs to have approval in the Orlando Conversion process Sign up physique, which happens to be consisting of local non secular plus immigration law authorities, a nearby administrator, women’s extramarital relationships ceo in addition to a local education and learning representative. [url=http://danielecerioni.com/collegamento.php?p=spaccio-moncler-trebaseleghe]spaccio moncler trebaseleghe[/url]
    Create one more label on the developing report on job hopefuls which may instructor the actual . [url=http://danielecerioni.com/collegamento.php?p=moncler-baby]moncler baby[/url]
    Get hold of A2z tony Hicks in and also .

  6. bloomington localized [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=doudoune-moncler-grise-femme]doudoune moncler grise femme[/url]
    It was not that long ago that any of us had been The show biz industry n ., with so many motion pictures, TV series in addition to commercials becoming recorded below which neighborhoods were worrying very much that they today whine regarding techies. [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=marque-moncler-doudoune]marque moncler doudoune[/url]
    Less than the numerous self-styled feminists which removed Lewinsky, such as America’s feminist primary lovely lady. Recentl [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=moncler-rouen]moncler rouen[/url]
    05/30/2014 3 years ago:50:12 In the evening PDTClick photography so that you can enlargeCal Hearth workers are employed at the actual arena of any small fire in close proximity to Pfeiffer Major On Express Car park on Feb 5th. (Vern Fisher : Monterey Usher in) [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=pharrell-williams-moncler]pharrell williams moncler[/url]
    Posted: [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=moncler-doudoune-site-officiel]moncler doudoune site officiel[/url]
    That will pitch presents the newest endeavor through the FCC in order to enshrine some understanding of internet neutrality, also called your “Open Internet.In [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=moncler-pas-cher-soldes]moncler pas cher soldes[/url]
    Simply by Lorna Rodriguez [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=doudoune-longue-moncler]doudoune longue moncler[/url]
    “It’s quite regarding in my opinion,” Burgis mentioned, the woman’s words stuffed with emotion while she documented this, in comparison, there were nine noted suicides throughout Oakley on the past 5yrs.

  7. Market Investigation Analyst Houston Faulhaber from Gormley, spends time with pursuits for example owning an antique car, nike free and storytelling. Discovers the charm in going to destinations around the globe, recently just returning from Jelling Mounds.

  8. BAHAMAIAN NATIONAL PLEADS Guilt ridden Throughout FAILED SMUGGLING Endeavor THAT Slain Some HAITIAN Ladies [url=http://sportingcupmp.com/product_id.php?p=moncler-giubbotti]moncler giubbotti[/url]
    05/21/2014 Summer:2007:59 Evening PDT [url=http://sportingcupmp.com/product_id.php?p=piumini-moncler-uomo]piumini moncler uomo[/url]
    Hill Shore — 7-10 g.mirielle., Foghorn’s upon Environment friendly Hectares, Fayetteville. [url=http://sportingcupmp.com/product_id.php?p=giubbotti-moncler]giubbotti moncler[/url]
    May 24, 2014 [url=http://sportingcupmp.com/product_id.php?p=outlet-moncler]outlet moncler[/url]
    A few. Coastkeeper Backyard garden. Wide open 6 a.meters. to be able to Four delaware.mirielle., this kind of eco friendly yard is absolutely six varieties of California environments, includes a great Organic Enjoy Backyard garden that just might motivate a myriad of trendy outside planting along with participate in at your residence. Workshops (intended for people) the first Thursday of each calendar month, 12 for you to Eleven. 8045 Age. Chapman Ave, Fruit. [url=http://sportingcupmp.com/product_id.php?p=piumini-donna-moncler]piumini donna moncler[/url]
    Colombian Web design manager Juan Red washington Santos has referred to this Alliance because Latin The us utes brand new economical as well as advancement motor. This sort of statements possess irritated Brazil, nevertheless. [url=http://sportingcupmp.com/product_id.php?p=moncler-outlet]moncler outlet[/url]
    He has not been depending upon a youtube video in the capturing going well-liked before the criminal offense landscape was de-activate.

  9. Fish [url=http://danielecerioni.com/collegamento.php?p=moncler-baby]moncler baby[/url]
    Numerous experience difficult treatment. [url=http://danielecerioni.com/collegamento.php?p=borse-moncler]borse moncler[/url]
    Well Re-size [url=http://danielecerioni.com/collegamento.php?p=moncler-giubbotti]moncler giubbotti[/url]
    The two Koreas routinely carry out artillery workouts inside disputed marine environments. The ocean border will not be certainly noticeable, and the location has been this picture involving 3 soft naval skirmishes relating to the competing Koreas because 2004. [url=http://danielecerioni.com/collegamento.php?p=moncler-uomo]moncler uomo[/url]
    Find out about our own and also . [url=http://danielecerioni.com/collegamento.php?p=giubbotti-moncler]giubbotti moncler[/url]
    Nevertheless, if knocked by simply Arcadia Creating to be able to start a 4 . subject for any businesses impending “Legendary Locals” collection, Bergtold balked. “After producing several publications with regards to Shedd Gatos, I did not imagine I’d any more to mention,” Bergtold a joke. [url=http://danielecerioni.com/collegamento.php?p=piumini-moncler-outlet]piumini moncler outlet[/url]
    Philbin ended up being slain inside Vietnam inside 1965, Rosenberger throughout ’68. [url=http://danielecerioni.com/collegamento.php?p=giubbotti-moncler]giubbotti moncler[/url]
    involving July. [url=http://danielecerioni.com/collegamento.php?p=moncler-baby]moncler baby[/url]
    There is certainly several common sense towards the lower-than-usual unusual taking part

  10. Voters, it is zero 12 months to take a seat out and about a principal political election. [url=http://www.picketreport.com/linksports.php?p=replica-gucci-belts]replica gucci belts[/url]
    DeCuire finished Mt inside The early 90′s having a education running a business advertising and marketing. [url=http://www.picketreport.com/linksports.php?p=gucci-outlet]gucci outlet[/url]
    The particular parliament — stunted simply by its very own government, which happens to be depressing for a revocation from the home’s consultations until brand new elections — provides called in the particular forces to deal with down pro-Hifter militias while in the capital. [url=http://www.picketreport.com/linksports.php?p=gucci-outlets]gucci outlets[/url]
    Currently the common earnings in Europe is 28,Thousand euro a year [url=http://www.picketreport.com/linksports.php?p=cheap-gucci-sunglasses]cheap gucci sunglasses[/url]
    Triple leap: Half-dozen, A long way Keys-Mckay, Santa claus Jackson, 43-10 ; 8-10, Kasem Eco-friendly, Watsonville, 43-08 . [url=http://www.picketreport.com/linksports.php?p=cheap-gucci-shoes]cheap gucci shoes[/url]
    This particular oped has been compiled by Pamela Conelly, Paola Luna, Eileen Reyes, in addition to Alyssa Roy, community occupants along with San Jose Condition grasp regarding public overall health pupils. [url=http://www.picketreport.com/linksports.php?p=wholesale-gucci-shoes]wholesale gucci shoes[/url]
    Shattered discs, coffee mugs and photographs with the about three former instructors may also be a part of the actual part creating a personalized feel. [url=http://www.picketreport.com/linksports.php?p=cheap-gucci-shoes]cheap gucci shoes[/url]
    He / she questioned anyone who videotaped Hernandez’s taking pictures to contact his workplace.

  11. You could certainly see your enthusiasm in the article you write.

    The sector hopes for even more passionate writers such as you who
    aren’t afraid to mention how they believe. Always go after your

  12. I don’t even understand how I stopped up here, however I believed this put up was great. I don’t realize who you might be however certainly you are going to a famous blogger if you happen to aren’t already. Cheers!

  13. In its place, the law involves “a rather weak” provision with regard to buddy in the courtroom briefs, which might be currently allowed less than active regulation. [url=http://danielecerioni.com/collegamento.php?p=outlet-moncler]outlet moncler[/url]
    In the event Slope is the winner the main, she is going to experience Democrat Pete Gosar, an airplane pilot, Don’t forget national. 4. [url=http://danielecerioni.com/collegamento.php?p=giubbotti-moncler]giubbotti moncler[/url]
    For all those curious about Plum cocinero , she actually is keeping this Daniel Patterson Class : as well as wishes to start some sort of S . fransisco diner. [url=http://danielecerioni.com/collegamento.php?p=giubbotto-moncler]giubbotto moncler[/url]
    To help Delsanto, “words are usually is situated,” particularly for a performer. [url=http://danielecerioni.com/collegamento.php?p=piumini-moncler-donna]piumini moncler donna[/url]
    Russia’s Top rated Researcher Bastrykin Protects Dying Charge A Moscow Moments May perhaps. 28 2014 19th:33 Final customized 19:Thirty-four Maxim Stulov Per VedomostiThe brain of Russia’s Investigative Board, Alexander Bastrykin, compared with eliminating the demise penalty as being a punishment. [url=http://danielecerioni.com/collegamento.php?p=piumini-moncler-outlet]piumini moncler outlet[/url]
    LSU Three, Auburn Zero (initial inning) [url=http://danielecerioni.com/collegamento.php?p=moncler-sito-ufficiale]moncler sito ufficiale[/url]
    Content published in Friday, Might 12-15, 2014

  14. Wonderful beat ! I wish to apprentice even as you amend your web site, how could i subscribe for a weblog site? The account aided me a applicable deal. I had been tiny bit acquainted of this your broadcast offered vibrant transparent idea

  15. I would like to thnkx for the efforts you have put in writing this web site. I’m hoping the same high-grade web site post from you in the upcoming also. In fact your creative writing abilities has inspired me to get my own blog now. Really the blogging is spreading its wings quickly. Your write up is a great example of it.
    Louis Vuitton Vente

  16. Nicely ResizeRecipe: Zucchini and Harissa Bruschetta [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=boutique-doudoune-moncler]boutique doudoune moncler[/url]
    Seats then can be purchased on the internet on or by means of dialing 800-745-3000. [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=moncler-pas-cher-chine]moncler pas cher chine[/url]
    Blew Reed plus the Flatheads — Hunting for p.l., Jack’s Spot, Eureka Arises. [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=doudoune-moncler-occasion]doudoune moncler occasion[/url]
    A number of while in the class ought to devoted to NCAA Division We plans — Munson for the Canada Nanooks on the College or university associated with Alaska Fairbanks; Lagrone using Co School; Gervais by using Clarkson University or college; and also Aldridge together with River Exceptional State Higher education. [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=moncler-pas-chere-homme]moncler pas chere homme[/url]
    Bradley mentioned he’s looking forward to reconciling with in the engagement ring. [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=bottes-moncler]bottes moncler[/url]
    Notification: Two times criteria about speechLETTER: Terrorists in Washington [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=bonnet-moncler-pas-cher]bonnet moncler pas cher[/url]
    Yet, as The state of utah Sen. Robert Lee records, “We’ll never promote our plan on survival reform while Republicans until eventually we present People in the usa we are able to receive Large Organization away from the dole.” That’s correct; really bad so few regarding his / her colleagues trust him or her.

  17. I am really impressed together with your writing abilities as neatly as with the structure for your weblog. Is that this a paid topic or did you customize it yourself? Either way stay up the nice quality writing, it’s rare to see a great blog like this one today..

  18. I’ve been exploring for a little bit for any high quality articles or weblog posts in this kind of house . Exploring in Yahoo I ultimately stumbled upon this web site. Studying this information So i’m happy to show that I’ve an incredibly good uncanny feeling I came upon just what I needed. I most for sure will make certain to do not put out of your mind this site and give it a glance regularly.

  19. I do agree with all of the ideas you have offered in your post. They are very convincing and will certainly work. Still, the posts are very quick for newbies. May you please extend them a little from next time? Thank you for the post.

  20. Though the greatest Jekyll-Hyde staff may be the Indiana Pacers. As being the East’s Zero. One seeds, the Pacers travelled the full several video games having eighth-seeded The atlanta area from the initially circular, and after that dropped two home game titles within the next round to help Buenos aires ahead of last but not least removing the Sorcerers within half a dozen game titles. [url=http://www.picketreport.com/linksports.php?p=gucci-purses-outlet]gucci purses outlet[/url]
    Greenback Shrub manages over 5 various,080 stores from the U.Ohydrates. along with Canada. Over the initial one fourth, this company opened 94 shops, shut down 6-8 in addition to expanded or perhaps shifted Twenty eight suppliers. [url=http://www.picketreport.com/linksports.php?p=wholesale-gucci-shoes]wholesale gucci shoes[/url]
    Well Re-size [url=http://www.picketreport.com/linksports.php?p=discount-gucci-handbags]discount gucci handbags[/url]
    Font ResizeThompson: Within Dorrie Kerr, Enthusiast obtain guy [url=http://www.picketreport.com/linksports.php?p=gucci-wholesale]gucci wholesale[/url]
    Well ResizeRoadshow: The actual beagle as well as ‘busybodies’ — just what audience saidBy Grettle Richards grichards@mercurynews.comPosted: [url=http://www.picketreport.com/linksports.php?p=cheap-gucci-belts]cheap gucci belts[/url]
    05/25/2014 12:Fifty-five:30 In the afternoon PDTUpdated: [url=http://www.picketreport.com/linksports.php?p=gucci-factory-outlet]gucci factory outlet[/url]
    By simply Michelle HARRIS [url=http://www.picketreport.com/linksports.php?p=white-gucci-belt]white gucci belt[/url]
     Scored the team-high 12-15 objectives being a mature, which include more effective in the four-game extend in which incorporated a couple of playoff is the winner. Closed together with Japanese Oklahoma Express.

  21. Should an additional main fire emerge regionally, Chaney claimed Calorie Hearth is actually ready for it. [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=moncler-montpellier]moncler montpellier[/url]
    The Science Fiction along with Fantasy Copy writers of America is definitely very happy to broadcast the actual SFWA Los angeles Reading through Collection. These kind of free every quarter occasions encourage the Sci-fi in addition to Dream area the opportunity to assemble, community, and luxuriate in psychic readings coming from from neighborhood in addition to going to writers. [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=chaussure-moncler]chaussure moncler[/url]
    This change approved Friday won’t take care of pastime usage of bud, which in turn Denver co along with Buenos aires voters authorized in 2012; national organizations up to now have never chipped documented on people states’ actions. [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=chaussures-moncler]chaussures moncler[/url]
    The lady claimed she believes that she is by far the most skilled candidate however contest, as a consequence of the woman’s reputation of helping attempt a local with a budget associated with poisonous of money without experiencing debts. [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=doudoune-moncler-en-ligne]doudoune moncler en ligne[/url]
    Thursday night 5/19 : Mostly clear. Minimal 49. [url=http://www.fil-nomade.com/product_id.php?p=moncler-eur]moncler eur[/url]
    Hang in there.

  22. Today, I went to the beach front with my kids.
    I found a sea shell and gave it to my 4 year old daughter and said
    “You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear.” She placed the shell to her ear
    and screamed. There was a hermit crab inside and it pinched her ear.
    She never wants to go back! LoL I know this is completely off topic but I had to
    tell someone!

    My web page :: Search results for: Javais Caaurai Voudrais Tout Plan Cul Reellement

  23. When someone writes an article he/she keeps the
    idea of a user in his/her brain that how a user can understand it.
    Thus that’s why this post is amazing. Thanks!

    Feel free to surf to my weblog :: locksmith for safe –

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>